I can confirm that Whoopie Pies are a staple in northeastern Indiana. My Mom used to make both the chocolate and the pumpkin versions. I believe that the local version used the Crisco-and-sugar mixture in the middle.
One thought on “Whoopie Pies”
Comments are closed.
I’ve made these before using my grandmother’s recipe. She was from SW Ohio and the filling was the Crisco/sugar mixture. Thanks for bring back a good memory.