Culinary Experimentation
I decided earlier this week to try out a few recipes from the blogosphere: Staci’s “Peanut Butter Balls” and that New York Times “No-Knead Bread” everybody‘s been talking about. Getting the bread started was easy; I just dumped everything in the bowl and mixed it together. I was worried that my dough wasn’t “wet” enough though, so I dumped in some more water. (Mistake.) After I had that covered and fermenting away, I went to work on the peanut butter balls. They’re basically the same as my Buckeyeballs, but with Rice Krispies mixed in. As usual though, I had difficulty getting the mixture stiff enough to roll into balls. I wonder if this is because I’m usually making these when it’s hot here, whereas in the Northern Hemisphere it’d be colder. I dunno. Anyway, those went into the freezer to set…
On Wednesday night, my dough looked suitably bubbly so I turned it out onto the floured counter and did the “fold and rest” thing. Then I gave it two hours for a secondary rise. Unfortunately… it didn’t. It was just way too wet and floppy. We decided to bake it anyway, and the result is the first loaf above. The crust was great but the inside was too dense and chewy. It just didn’t rise (and possibly bake) long enough. The peanut butter balls waited in the freezer til Friday night, when I dipped half of them using the leftover white chocolate from Halloween. I did the rest of them with milk chocolate on Saturday night. They’re not as pretty as Staci’s, but man they’re good! I’ve eaten about seventeen. Ugh. Saturday night we also started a second batch of the bread, this time obeying the recipe weights exactly. We put it in the office to rise (since the abundance of computers makes it warm in here). Today we turned it out… and again, the second rise was underwhelming. It’s supposed to double in size, and it just didn’t! This batch was much less wet though, and the resulting loaf was much less dense. The crust is incredibly crunchy though. Maybe I gave it too long with the lid off? I have a feeling we’re going to be playing with this process a bit.
M-H
December 18, 2006 — 8:57 am
I used to make a *lot* of bread (in the days before breadmakers), but I found that ‘no-knead’ type breads never had a good texture. I suppose that the gluten doesn’t get as well-developed using this process. I enjoy kneading and I’m impatient – I’d prefer to kned and then eat the same day!
aim
December 18, 2006 — 12:27 pm
How funny…I have problems getting my buckeyes to be firm, too! They’re always too mushy and then I usually overcompensate by making them way too dry…huh!
Kris
December 18, 2006 — 1:10 pm
Yeah, I compensate by adding more sugar, but then Rodd complains that they’re too disgustingly sweet and won’t eat them. More for me!
Max
December 18, 2006 — 1:26 pm
Kris, your first bread loaf LOOKS great, even if it didn’t pass a taste test. I’ve done way too much poking around on various foodie boards and such about the bread, and I think you’re not alone in your issues. The rise on all of my loaves (I’m in the double-digits now!) is always small…most people (myself included) agree that the only way to get a “tall” loaf is to cook it in a small and tall container (I do mine in a Calphalon 2.5-qt. saucepan with lid). And it may just be a matter of taste as far as the super-crunchy crust (I worry that mine will cut the inside of my mouth sometimes!) and chewy inside goes, because I think that’s the result Bittman was going for. I do 20-25 minutes with the lid on, then 10-15 with the lid off.
Anyway, I say keep playing around with it until you like it…or just fold in some cheese, yo! Seriously, it makes killer cheese bread, all dense and delicious.
Max
December 18, 2006 — 1:31 pm
I forgot to add that even the botched attempts at the bread (I’ve had my share) taste great when you throw them in a bowl of soup or slather them in jam. Oh, and next weekend we’re making French Toast with it. I’m drooling already.
Frances
December 20, 2006 — 3:04 am
What kind of peanut butter did you use on your peanut butter balls? I have to use JIF peanut butter because any other brand that I have tried has been way too oily and doesn’t get firm enough to roll.
Kris
December 20, 2006 — 7:43 am
No Jif here! I just used store brand. It’s an interesting thought though. I did notice that there was a lot of oil in the plastic storage container once the balls were all gone. Presumably it was peanut oil that seeped through.